CodeIgniter, The one semi decent framework… is done

I’ve been playing around with CodeIgniter, and although I’m not a huge fan of 3rd party PHP frameworks, I would have to say that CodeIgniter is probably the easiest out of the box solution. Of course, I still have to build everything that I need for it. It’s not like it comes with an image cropper, or a customized user profile area already built, but for its MVC structure, it’s pretty decent.

I’ve recently started to dabble in its query-ing capabilities. Although I like writing sql queries out by hand, and yes, insert them into my PHP code (model files under my models folders), what it has is a decent enough, and simple way to do get and set some data. Not bad… Until you come up to a query like this:

SELECT id, ( 3959 * acos ( cos ( radians(78.3232) ) * cos( radians( lat ) ) * cos( radians( lng ) - radians(65.3234) ) + sin ( radians(78.3232) ) * sin( radians( lat ) ) ) ) AS distance FROM markers HAVING distance < 30 ORDER BY distance LIMIT 0 , 20;

At which point… why even bother to use an ORM, or DAO? You’re just going to mix up your code anyway… Stop trying to write everything in PHP. MySQL is powerful as is without abstract layers.

Anyway, that’s one point. The other is all of the session and cookie handing.

Why load an entire new class, object, etc like $this->load->library(‘session’); when all you really need is $_SESSION. Done! All for the purpose of writing saving some additional info that you rarely use, or can gather any other way? I suppose it’s a shortcut that needs to be learned, but PHP already does that in its way.

The best feature, which it took a little convincing, was its MVC structure. Although I like to develop modularly (MVC structure should be kept in modules, not in the entire site), I was ok with its structure, considering that I can build folders for all of my “modules” but then I would have the same module folder in three different places.

The routing for it was something that was all right. It didn’t wow me. Basically, we took htaccess rewrite conditions and converted them into an array… Sigh… 6 of a kind, half a dozen. htaccess is faster though if you want to talk performance.

So in finale, it was probably the easiest to pick up and go with, considering its learning curve and its openness to be more like PHP.